The Good Guys
Seen it Cheaper?1300 942 765
Preferred Store:
loading...

The Big Question: Should You Repair Or Replace A Broken Fridge?

January 21, 2025-3 min read

A hardworking fridge-freezer is the cornerstone of any kitchen. So what happens when it stops doing what it’s supposed to do? From faulty ice-makers to dodgy seals or – the worst of the worst – an ominous warm breeze when you open the door, there comes a time in every fridge’s life when you have to stop and consider: do I fix it or upgrade?

Here, we let you in on the telltale signs that your cold companion needs some attention, and we break down the pros and cons of repairing your refrigerator or freezer, or replacing it with a more advanced, energy-efficient model. Maybe it's time for that lust-have French door fridge or space-laden side by side fridge!

Woman removes a can of soft drink from the fridge in her highend apartment kitchen

Warning Signs Your Fridge Is On The Blink

The most obvious sign your fridge is failing? It’s no longer keeping your food cold. Here are some other giveaways:.

Your fridge is freezing If your iceberg lettuce is solid enough to sink the Titanic, you have a problem. Your fridge should not reach freezing point. The temperature sensors might be faulty or a leaky door seal could be to blame.

Puddles of water It’s never good news when water leaks onto the kitchen floor. Not only is it a slip hazard, it might be the freezer defrosting, or internal hoses may have deteriorated or burst.

Food is spoiling The interior fridge temperature could be too warm or inconsistent. Not good!

Your fridge sounds like a plane taking off As a general rule, the bigger the fridge, the more noise it makes. However, if the decibel level has spiked, you might have cause for concern.

Replace Or Repair: Factors To Consider

So, when do you repair and when do you replace? There are a few variables: it will depend on the age of the fridge, if it’s still fit for use, and the potential cost of a fridge repair.

“Some fridge problems can be very expensive to fix. So if the cost of the repair is more than half the cost of a new fridge, you’re better off replacing it,” says Peter Simic, The Good Guys Buyer – Refrigeration and Laundry.

Modern fridges also have improved energy efficiencies that can save you money in the long run.

Shop Feature-Packed Fridges

LG 635L Side By Side Refrigerator

Haier 508L Quad Door Refrigerator

A woman opens the door of an integrated fridge in her modern and lightfilled kitchen

What To Look For When Shopping For A New Fridge

The silver lining to your fridge expiring? Now you can upgrade to a new model with smart tech and features, such as Wi-Fi connectivity. Cue the Samsung 809L AI Family Hub Refrigerator, which lets you order groceries from the touchscreen on the fridge door, or manage the family calendar!

Looking to save on running costs with the latest energy-efficient features? The LG InstaView fridge range offers a novel ‘knock twice’ glass window that lets you peek inside rather than opening the door.

Still on best fridges for families, the Westinghouse 609L French Door Refrigerator has a special easy-reach SnackZone designed to stock the nibbles you’re happy for the kids to grab.

“When buying a new fridge, consider how you might use it. If you have a big family or love entertaining, then a large-capacity French Door fridge is ideal. If you eat out most nights, a smaller fridge would be cheaper to run,” suggests Peter Simic.

Shop Next-Gen Fridges

LG 635L InstaView SxS Refrigerator

Electrolux 609L French Door Refrigerator

Fisher & Paykel 538L Quad Door Refrigerator

Fridge Maintenance Tips And Advice

Decided to upgrade? Follow these quick tips to make your new fridge go the distance.

  • Your refrigerator isn’t a shelf! Keep the top exterior surface clear to prevent overheating.

  • Check and clean the door seals regularly to keep cool air in.

  • Don’t overstuff your fridge. It won’t run efficiently and may overheat.

  • Don’t block the vents inside – you’ll reduce cooling power.

  • Defrost regularly.

Why It Pays To Upgrade With The Good Guys

Ready for a cool change? Our fridge and freezer buying guides are a great place to start before you upgrade. Then visit us in-store or online to find your perfect fridge.

¤Discounts apply to previous ticketed/advertised price prior to the discount offer. As we negotiate, products will likely have been sold below ticketed/advertised price prior to the discount offer.

.

Store Cash Wallet

>Qualifying conditions, including signing up to 90 Day StoreCash, activating a Digital Wallet before being eligible to earn/win and where a qualifying purchase is required, collecting the product within 60 days. 90 Day StoreCash expires 90 days after issue. Personal purchases only. Exclusions and purchase limits apply. Each 90 Day StoreCash reward must be used in one transaction and no change/credit for any unused balance. Refer to 90 Day StoreCash T&Cs for details, including how to receive 90 Day StoreCash deposit notifications, how to earn & timing for issue of 90 Day StoreCash.